Add Feeds
Publisher Windows
Streaming Headlines
Streaming Windows

Log out

Social Connect

OR Log into your Account below
Want One? Create New Account
"Criticising" and “Shaming” are Not the Same Things

"Criticising" and “Shaming” are Not the Same Things

| by Roger Yates

Dr. Melanie Joy is best known in the animal advocacy movement for developing a concept that describes a sub-ideology of speciesism called “Carnism”.


She recently wrote a blog entry about “vegans shaming other vegans.” She was angered that a small non-violent protest occurred at the International Animal Rights Conference in Luxembourg, where she was speaking along with colleagues Sebastian Zösch, the managing director of the German Vegetarian Association (VEBU), and Tobias Leenaert, founder of a government-funded vegetarian organisation in Belgium.



Two activists disrupted Zösch’s talk. One held up a banner reading: “Animal Rights NOT Animal Profit. VEBU: Effectively Wasting Veganism,” while another made an announcement about what many vegan advocates seem to think are problematic elements of VEBU’s activities. From what I can gather, the protest was entirely non-violent, although one source suggested that the body of a chicken had been thrown during the protest.


The activist’s main complaint seems to be that Zösch’s organisation is working with those they describe as the “worst animal exploiters.” I was subsequently sent this picture of a VEBU approved product which is 71% made from hens’ eggs.



Melanie Joy claims that this action amounted to “vegans shaming vegans” and called for the establishment of a “shame free culture.” She recognises something that is reflected in social movement theory: that discussion is important in social movements but urges that, “we approach our disagreements with curiosity and compassion.”


This all seems fairly reasonable – but I fear that Dr. Joy is confusing “shaming” with criticising and protesting. This action appeared to “fit” into the long tradition of non-violent direct action and, let’s not forget, it took place at the International Animal Rights Conference which is overwhelmingly vegan in orientation and is attended in the main by animal activists from all over Europe and beyond.


Rather than even being surprised by this protest and its alleged “shaming” content, perhaps the question is more fundamental: how appropriate is it that vegetarian organisations present at animal rights events? 


Melanie Joy, Mr. Zösch, and Mr. Leenaert are leading figures in an ongoing backlash against consistent veganism, criticising the concept of veganism being the “moral baseline” of the movement, trying to reduce the philosophy of veganism to a diet and, in the case of Zösch and Leenaert, being involved in a crude social construction of consistent vegan advocacy as the product of robotic people who may be mentally ill.



Given this context of the current backlash against the philosophy of veganism, perhaps the non-violent protest at Luxembourg was to be expected and, moreover, who is shaming whom?

Get Involved! If you have a great Vegan news feed, blog, podcast or video channel that you’d like us to include your focus on in the site, then please just contact us at with details!

Post Comment
Join the conversation!Log in to leave a comment.

Latest News

from Vegfest UK


Best of Brighton Holiday Lettings – Apartments, cottages and holidays in Brighton

Best of Brighton Holiday Lettings is one of Brighton’s leading

Encona Sauces – show sponsors of VegfestUK Brighton 2019

A massive welcome to Encona Sauces – show sponsors of VegfestUK

VegfestUK Brighton taking a break for 2020

The organisers of the annual VegfestUK Brighton event have

VegfestUK Brighton 2019 – Event Programme now available to view online

The full event programme for the first VegfestUK event of the year

BS Food Vegan and Organic Certified Sport and Wellness Supplements

A world where people, wildlife and nature can thrive together BS

Animal Think Tank to Host Movement Building Stream at Brighton Vegfest 2019

VegfestUK Brighton 2019 will feature a brand-new series of talks

BS Food Vegan and Organic Certified Sport and Wellness Supplements

A world where people, wildlife and nature can thrive together BS

Plant Based Health at VegfestUK Brighton 2019 – full schedule of talks and panels confirmed

The full lineup of speakers and topics have just been confirmed in

Celebrate Veganuary by visiting your local vegan festivals

As Veganuary is well and truly underway and we look forward to a

Global Feast of Plant-Based Cuisine at VegfestUK Brighton 2019

VegfestUK Brighton has in store a wide range of delectable and

VegfestUK Brighton 2019 – Advance Tickets now on sale with BOGOF until end of February

Advance tickets to the 11th VegfestUK Brighton are now on sale,

VegfestUK organisers welcome exciting new features at Brighton 2019 – Animal Think Tank, Plant-Based Health, Permaculture, Fitness, Yoga. Radical Veganism

The organisers of one of the UK’s biggest vegan events VegfestUK

Animal Think Tank makes its debut at VegfestUK Brighton 2019

VegfestUK Brighton 2019, one of the biggest vegan festivals in the

Plant-based Health Professionals UK to host health talks at VegfestUK Brighton 2019

VegfestUK – organisers of some of the UK’s largest vegan events –

VegfestUK Brighton 2019 – website now live for stall bookings

The show website for the 11th annual VegfestUK Brighton in 2019 is

VegfestUK London 2018 – Event Programme now available to read online

The full event programme for this year’s VegfestUK London is now

MariPharm – producers of top-quality CBD products

VegfestUK welcomes new sponsors MariPharm for their upcoming vegan

Oumph! – Epic veggie eating for free range humans!

The VegfestUK team extends a warm welcome to this year’s new

Radical Veganism talks and panels at VegfestUK London 2018

The Radical Veganism talks room returns to VegfestUK London on

Statement on the future of VegfestUK Bristol

The organisers of the annual vegan festival VegfestUK in Bristol

About The Vegfest Express
Brought to you by Vegfest UK
Get the latest Vegan Recipes, Videos, Podcasts and News on Animals, Environment and Vegan Products, all curated by experts in the field. Want your blog or site featured on The Vegfest Express? Contact Us!
Contact Us
Follow Us