Add Feeds
Publisher Windows
Streaming Headlines
Streaming Windows

Log out

Social Connect

OR Log into your Account below
Want One? Create New Account
Email:
Password:
Dr. Roger Yates - An Introduction to the Controversial Idea of Animal Rights

Dr. Roger Yates - An Introduction to the Controversial Idea of Animal Rights

2016-05-08 
| by Roger Yates

At VegFestUK Bristol, I will be running a short 30-minute “workshop” entitled, “An Introduction to the Controversial Idea of Animal Rights.”

Sunday May 22nd between 3:00 – 3:30 pm in the Activists Workshops area

 

So, what’s controversial about the idea of animal rights? Claims about animal rights certainly have a long history – in terms of there being an animal rights movement, the work of Tom Regan, the author of The Case for Animal Rights in 1983 must be cited, and many talk about an earlier newspaper article published in 1965 by Bridget Brophy (“The Rights of Animals,” in the Sunday Times on October 10, 1965) as very significant: indeed, warranting a conference in 2015 marking the article’s 50th year.

 

 

What’s controversial is that we have an “animal rights movement” which does just about everything else but embrace rights. In other words, we do not have a rights-based animal rights movement.

 

The philosopher of choice in the animal movement (to the extent that there is one) is Peter Singer, author of Animal Liberation (1975), the book described by Jean Pink, the founder of Animal Aid in 1977, as “the bible of the new animal rights movement,” whereas Singer himself complains that the book has nothing to do with rights, certainly not moral rights.

 

 

Most national animal organisations stock Animal Liberation, whereas rights-based books are few and far between. PeTA, the multinational sexist and racist group, blatantly lie about Animal Liberation, claiming it to be an animal rights text. To this day, PeTA USA have a box on the front page of their website, entitled “Why Should Animals Have Rights?” It links directly to Animal Liberation rather than a rights-based text.

 

So, who cares and why does it matter?

 

The people who want to make rights a fundamental part of their animal advocacy certainly care. However, there’s a more fundamental reason why a “real” animal rights movement needs to flourish – or be “rebooted” as I said in a recent and related blog entry. For one thing, it would change our claims-making. [1]

 

The current animal advocacy movement does not make rights-based claims. For example, it is very rare to find references to right-holding, or rights bearing, in the movement’s literature. If that’s found anywhere, it will be in the literature made independently by grassroots groups. Can you remember hearing many movement spokespeople talk about rights violations – saying, for example, that the human use of other animals are rights violations?

 

 

An active rights-based movement would also help us understand the important differences between moral and legal rights, and positive and negative rights.

 

So – I think that lot will keep us busy for half an hour!



[1]. In terms of social movement theory, social movements are seen as claims makers in civil society. They often identify what they see as a problem, or set of problems and then make related claims. For example, the feminist movement saw a problem in the patriarchal structure of society and the systematic discrimination and abuse that flowed from that. Feminists made claims about respecting women’s rights, for example, and advocated legal changes related to employment, pay, and voting rights - and, in some cases, called for a widespread revolutionary shift in gender relations.

 

Check out other vegan news worldwide on the online vegan magazine www.vegfestexpress.co.uk 

Get your advance tickets to VegfestUK Bristol at www.bristol.vegfest.co.uk/admission

Full event programme at www.bristol.vegfest.co.uk/programme 

Get Involved! If you have a great Vegan news feed, blog, podcast or video channel that you’d like us to include in The Vegfest Express, or if you have any ideas of new Vegan topics that you’d like us to focus on in the site, then please just contact us at info@vegfest.co.uk with details!






Post Comment
Join the conversation!Log in to leave a comment.

Subscribe to our newsletter

* indicates required
VegfestUK event(s) of interest:

Latest News

from Vegfest UK

15 HRS AGO

Original independent vegan hemp company Yaoh – helping fuel the growth of both hemp and veganism in the UK

One of the UK’s original hemp companies Yaoh has played an
02/07/2018

50% off discount on Yaoh moisturisers from July – August 2018

Yaoh’s range of moisturisers will be available on a 50% discount
01/07/2018

50% off discount on Yaoh moisturisers from July – August 2018

Yaoh’s range of moisturisers will be available on a 50% discount
29/05/2018

First-ever vegan festival at Ashton Gate stadium attracted around 9,000 people

The home of Bristol City football club hosted its largest
12/05/2018

Event programme for VegfestUK Bristol 2018 now available to view online

The full event programme for the VegfestUK Bristol vegan festival
04/05/2018

Shuttle bus service available for those travelling to VegfestUK Bristol

First Group bus service will be kindly operating a special shuttle
01/05/2018

Joyous occasion for families with kids at Ashton Gate on May Bank Holiday Weekend – under 16’s FREE

Families with kids will have lots of incentive to visit the
25/04/2018

Switch to Ecotricity and receive a FREE £50 voucher to spend at The Vegan Kind Supermarket

It’s really easy to get a quote – just answer a couple of
25/04/2018

Vegan professional basketball player Daniel Edozie from Bristol Flyers to speak at VegfestUK Bristol

The lineup of athletes at VegfestUK Bristol at Ashton Gate has an
20/04/2018

Ujima Live Acts Stage lineup confirmed for VegfestUK Bristol 2018

Ujima Radio 98fm has recently run an online poll with slots to
20/04/2018

Legendary Bristol-based house DJ Mikee Freedom confirmed at VegfestUK Bristol 2018

Amazing news for everyone looking forward to soaking up the
17/04/2018

Diverse range of global vegan cuisine available at VegfestUK Bristol 2018

VegfestUK events are renowned as hotbeds of fine and sumptuous
17/04/2018

Vegan comedian Andrew O’Neill headlines Sunday part of Comedy at VegfestUK Bristol

Super-exciting news for everybody planning to visit VegfestUK
10/04/2018

The Art of Compassion Exhibition is back with VegfestUK at Ashton Gate stadium on May 26-27

After their successful exhibitions at the last 2 VegfestUK events
09/04/2018

VegfestUK Bristol billboard posters now up at various poster sites in Bristol

Excitement for the upcoming VegfestUK Bristol on May 26-27 at
05/04/2018

Paid role with flyer distribution for VegfestUK Bristol available in April – May

The organisers of VegfestUK Bristol 2018 are looking to fill a paid
02/04/2018

Ashton Gate stadum’s 3-course vegan meals for VegfestUK Bristol now open for bookings

Exciting news as the 3-course vegan meals offered by Ashton Gate
02/04/2018

Policy for Visitors with Disabilities at VegfestUK Bristol 2018

The following policy aims to assist visitors with disabilities to
27/03/2018

Around 7,400 visitors sampled vegan delights at VegfestUK Brighton 2018

Big thanks to everyone who attended this year’s VegfestUK Brighton
21/03/2018

VegfestUK enters Ashton Gate stadium in style on May 26th-27th 2018

VegfestUK Bristol moves into the new venue of Ashton Gate stadium

About The Vegfest Express
Brought to you by Vegfest UK
Get the latest Vegan Recipes, Videos, Podcasts and News on Animals, Environment and Vegan Products, all curated by experts in the field. Want your blog or site featured on The Vegfest Express? Contact Us!
Contact Us
Follow Us