Vegfest Express Skip to content

Reports

The inherent problems with vegans advocating reducetarianism

Filed · From the VegfestUK news archive

A small stage with a lectern and a row of plain trophies on a draped table (AI-generated image) AI
Awards stage · AI-generated imageFIG. 01

Reducetarianism, as defined by its founder Brian Kateman, is the act of aspiring to reduce one's intake of meat. As an occasional meat-eater who acknowledges bacon’s appeal, Kateman thinks the “less rather than none” message is more appealing than that of vegan or vegetarian campaigners. It's no surprise that someone who is not vegan does not advocate the concept of veganism that he isn't yet practising. However, a quick glance at the ‘Supporters’ page of the reducetarian website www.reducetarian.org reveals a number of high-profile vegans who are giving the reducetarian concept a big thumbs-up.

Many of these vegans do mean well in that they promote reducetarianism with the intent of luring non-vegans into a comfort zone where they become exempt from moral judgements, rather than pushing them further away from the end goal of veganism by telling them that they're not good enough. As a matter of fact, less exploitation of animals is always better than more exploitation of animals. Moreover, the reduced consumption of animal products, if carried out to significant amounts, has undeniable benefits for human health, for the environment and for sustainable food production too.

However, does using animals in reduced quantities justify imposing suffering and death on them in the first place, all of which involves no necessity whatsoever? Does moderating exploitation of animals address the fundamental rights violation that comes with exploiting animals?

Why animal exploitation involves fundamental rights violation

Using animals for food, clothing, entertainment, cosmetics or research necessitates treating animals as economic resources at the mercy of human beings – an act only justified by a 'species barrier' that is completely irrelevant to whether any sentient being with capacities for desires, pleasure and pain should have their lives dictated by others.

Sure, humans and non-humans have very different ways of perceiving reality and communicate by totally different means. So some rights that humans enjoy don't apply to non-human animals. For instance, we won't accord animals the right to drive vehicles, go to universities or to vote. However, when it comes to merely not being used as a resource for others – which is just another way of describing slavery - all human-like cognitive characteristics except sentience become irrelevant. Otherwise, we could say that those who are more intelligent are entitled to enslave those who are less intelligent.

We oppose racism, sexism, heterosexism, etc for the very reason that no sentient beings should have their fundamental interests devalued or removed from them based on irrelevant criteria (of race, gender, sexual orientation etc). If we object to racism, sexism, heterosexism, etc based on such premise, we are also morally obligated to oppose speciesism – the devaluation of another sentient being's interests of avoiding suffering and continuing their lives based on species.

Why promoting reduced animal exploitation validates fundamental rights violation

As a theoretical matter, promoting the reduction, rather than rejection, of animal exploitation, only serves to reiterate the pervasive, normative and speciesist paradigm, that animals are ours to use and we have the right to quantify how much we use them as resources. This is no different from saying a slave owner has the choice to beat up his slave nine times a day instead of ten times a day. Many would object to the concept of less beatings of slaves but would accept the concept of less exploitation of animals for food (and clothing, entertainment, cosmetics, research etc). This is blatant speciesism, the ideology that devalues the fundamental interests of animals not to be treated as chattel property based on the irrelevant criteria of a 'species barrier'.

The reducetarian concept focuses only on meat

The top of the reducetarian website www.reducetarian.org says.

“Aspire to eat less meat? Then you're a reducetarian!”

As animal use is so pervasive in our society, by implication, this slogan draws an artificial moral distinction between the animals used for flesh, and the animals used for dairy and eggs, and the sea animals used for seafood. As a matter of fact, there isn't any. If anything, dairy cows are kept alive longer than beef cattle, and the former endure even more suffering due to a repeated cycle of enforced pregnancy (i.e. rape), having their babies taken away at birth, and having their udders squeezed to breaking point for their milk, and dairy cows end up in the same slaughterhouses as beef cattle anyway. The egg and fish industries account for the higher amounts of animal deaths across all industries that churn out animal-based food for human consumption. The idea that simply cutting out or reducing meat consumption alone eliminates a significant amount of animal suffering and death is sheer fantasy.

If vegans promote non-veganism, does that mean non-vegans don’t have to go vegan?

Reducetarians outnumber vegans all over the globe and celebrity reducetarians on fad diets occupy the press in increasing regularity. Surely reducetarians who still find it acceptable to exploit animals but do it less for their own well-being, are well qualified to promote the virtues of reducetarianism themselves. However, if those adhering to veganism for ethical reasons are telling people that they don't have to go vegan but they can do their bit simply by reducing their meat, what message does this send out to non-vegans? This suggests that they don't need to go vegan after all, that the whole vegan ethos is frivolous, and that mere reduction of meat is an end in itself. This is like feminists saying rape is fine as long as it's done in rationed amounts, or racial equality activists advocating racist-joke free Monday campaigns. The message that gets spread out in either instance is that the end goal that activists are supposedly campaigning for is not worth fighting for after all.

Plus, if the currently outnumbered ethical vegans default in their duty to promote ethical veganism as the moral baseline, who else will take on the mantle of shifting the paradigm away from 'animals as property' to 'animals as persons'?

Why the means must be consistent with their ends

If we want a vegan world as our end goal, we must promote unequivocal veganism as a means that is consistent with our ends. We can never move closer to our goal by promoting means that are at odds with their supposed ends. Reducetarianism promotes less exploitation as a legitimate means to no exploitation. As a logical matter, this is the same as saying, “I want X but I promote the opposite of X instead”, which is as counterintuitive as it can get. This is akin to someone who wants to end war by promoting warfare, or a women rights organisation who wants to eliminate rape by running a rape-free Monday campaign. These 'reducetarian' campaigns in the human rights context merely reinforce the notion that fundamental rights violations are acceptable as long as they are carried out in moderation.

But the reducetarian campaign is 'effective'!

First of all, by what means, and by what yardstick, should we measure the effectiveness of a campaign geared towards changing people's dietary habits?

It is next to frivolous to measure the efficacy of the reducetarian campaign based on how much meat (and other animal products) people reduce. After all, the word 'reducetarian' is by definition imprecise in stating how much exactly people should reduce. So anyone can become a reducetarian just by removing one drop of milk from their breakfast tea, or leaving out the skins on their chicken nuggets!

Maybe we ought to measure the success of the campaign based on how many new vegans it creates?

Or, as proponents of reducetarianism suggest, once people take the first step towards reducing their meat, they might eventually see the connection between meat, dairy, eggs, fish and the animals used for other purposes?

To this date, we have yet to see any peer-reviewed research measuring success based on how many new vegans the reducetarian approach has created. The only recent 'research' that has been circulated amongst supporters of reducetarianism is a report published by the Humane League Labs in August 2015.

https://humaneleaguelabs.files.wordpress.com/2015/09/humane-league-labs-best-request2.pdf

In a nutshell, the study assembled a group of approximately 1,600 participants with the goal of measuring which of the following educational booklets is most effective in getting people to change their diets.

- a booklet that says “eat vegan”

- a booklet that says “eat vegetarian”

- a booklet that says “eat less meat”

- a booklet that says “cut out or cut back on meat and animal products”

The study.

- asked participants to fill in an initial survey on how frequently they consume red meat, poultry, fish, eggs, and dairy products

- provided each respondent with a booklet, allowing them to read the booklet for as long or short of a time as they wanted

- followed up respondents by email between 2 and 4 months after reading the booklets, and asked them to take another survey on how frequently they consumed red meat, poultry, fish, eggs, and dairy products

The study included a control group that were not shown any booklet at all.

This study is however fundamentally flawed on many different levels.

- the control group actually gave rise to the most significant reduction of animal consumption

- the study has never been scientifically peer-reviewed

- its response rate was low (less than 50% of the participants who completed the initial survey on their dietary habits completed the follow up survey on their dietary changes between 2 and 4 months after reading the booklets)

- the booklet which advocates an unequivocal vegan message is described as 'purist' which implies the inherent bias in the study

In fact, Dr. Casey Taft has written an excellent analysis debunking the findings in the Humane League study as nothing but 'pseudoscience'.

http://veganpublishers.com/pseudoscience/

But we need 'publicity'!

Some proponents of reducetarianism point to its press coverage and celebrity supporters as reasons alone for supporting it. Of course, a campaign that makes people feel better without asking them to make too many lifestyle choices is always media-friendly – it’s not rocket science at all.

Publicity is a double-edged sword. To a mass audience, it can perpetuate a morally coherent message, or do the exact opposite. As much as it has entered mainstream media and attracted the support from celebrities ever since its inception, the reducetarian campaign broadly reinforces the speciesist and hierarchical notion that animals, as the victims, are merely property that humans, the victimisers, get to decide how much to exploit. Promoting such speciesist notion via the mainstream only further entrenches the existing paradigm that animals are commodities for humans to use. Any non-vegan on the receiving end of such ‘feel good, do little’ propaganda will simply find it more comfortable to continue using animals for their own purposes.

But people aren't going to go vegan overnight!

Of course those who are unapologetic about being 100% vegan understand completely that, with the paradigm shift that needs to take place, the world is not going to go vegan overnight. The matter in question is whether 'mere reduction as a morally good thing to pursue' is the message that vegans should be sending out.

Those who are already concerned about the plight of animals, who have heard the vegan message, but who feel that they're 'not quite ready yet' to go 100% vegan, will undoubtedly pursue their own 'reducetarian' steps anyway. If they choose to go reducetarian, that should be their own choice, not something that vegans should advocate as a morally good thing to do.

Obviously vegans should give non-vegans as much support as possible on going vegan. Make it clear though, that we support them to go vegan, but we don't support going veggie, reducetarian, or meat-free, dairy-free, etc. If people really really need to take an incremental approach to veganism, make it clear that.

- this is not an ideal approach, since numerous animals are still being used as property for the purposes of the non-vegan whilst incremental steps are pursued.

- stick to the word 'vegan' in all incremental steps, e.g. vegan Monday, vegan Tuesday, etc. or vegan breakfast, vegan lunch, vegan dinner, vegan snacks. No free-range meat, no crate-free pork, no grass-fed milk, no enriched-cage eggs. No vegetarianism. No reducetarianism.

Unequivocal vegan education does not mean alienating people.

On the contrary, veganism, as an unwavering commitment to non-violence, is the most peaceful concept that has ever existed in an entire human history built on exploitation of the vulnerable. If a vegan world consists of beautiful and sumptuous recipes such as the below, and peace-loving folks advocating the beauty of non-violence, surely a vegan world is something to be embraced rather than cringed upon?

It's up to the vegans in us to shine the light of veganism onto those who are not yet vegans, and awaken the seed of compassion already ingrained in an overwhelming majority of them. Most of them already agree with the principle of non-violence, and they are all ripe candidates for creative, peaceful, unequivocal vegan education. Invite them to do the morally right thing for non-human animals, and that means going vegan, living vegan, and staying vegan.

With unequivocal vegan education, the UK could be vegan in 10 years!

A conservative estimate, based on figures from 2006, on the number of vegans in the UK is an approximate 150,000. The current UK population is approximately 65,000,000. If each of these vegans convinces just one other non-vegan to become vegan each year, and this repeats every year, the UK will be 100% vegan in merely a decade.

150,000

300,000

600,000

1,200,000

2,400,000

4,800,000

9,600,000

19,200,000

38,400,000

76,800,000

Of course this will require mobilising every vegan in the UK to get active and educate others to become vegan through creative, peaceful vegan education. To get to a vegan UK in 10 years, therefore, requires a revolution of the heart from everyone. Each one of us needs to become a self-leader in educating ourselves about veganism and promoting veganism in our own communities. It’s time to take matters into our own hands and work towards creating a vegan world through unequivocal vegan education.

Recent discussion on ‘reducetarianism’

Vegan events to help you go vegan

In fact, check out many amazing vegan festivals in the UK where you can enjoy good vegan company on top of some amazing vegan food, life-changing vegan education and uplifting entertainment. See www.vegfest.co.uk for details.

Stay tuned to the Vegfest Express www.vegfestexpress.co.uk for the latest vegan news happening across the globe.

Subscribe to VegfestUK TV www.youtube.com/vegfestuktv for videos of selected talks recorded from previous Vegfest events.

Further materials on veganism

For further info on how to go vegan, visit.

www.HowDoIGoVegan.com

For answers to FAQ's from non-vegans, check out the book “Eat Like You Care: An Examination of the Morality of Eating Animals”,.

www.EatLikeYouCareBook.com

Alternatively, check out this excellent commentary from Prof. Gary L. Francione on how to talk to non-vegans about veganism.

To learn more about the Abolitionist Approach to Animal Rights, visit.

www.AbolitionistApproach.com

www.facebook.com/abolitionistapproach

and check out the latest book “Animal Rights: the Abolitionist Approach” which you can purchase either as paperback or on Kindle,.

www.AbolitionistApproachBook.com

More from Reports

More from Reports

REF: 15-12 Reports
An outdoor market in spring with blossom on a tree above the stalls (AI-generated image) AI AI-generated image

Tim Barford – The Future of The Vegan Society

I can do more to protect & promote veganism, democracy & the future of The Vegan Society from outside Council than inside so I have resigned as a Trustee.

08 DEC 2015
REF: 15-12 Reports
Visitors in wet coats browsing an indoor hall with rain on the skylight (AI-generated image) AI AI-generated image

Turn Up The Beet

Beet juice is highly potent and according to studies, improves athletic performance! Here is a beet juice recipe by the Vegan Fitness Angel.

08 DEC 2015