Reports
We Are in a Numbers Game
Filed · A guest post
The vast majority of human beings are brought up and effectively trained to be speciesists by a powerful social ideology that says we are the most important beings on the planet: an ideology that even denies that humans are animals. Humans do not celebrate being apes. How many people think that the term “animal” is an insulting label to apply to a human being? As vegans we also know that most humans tend not to self-identify as mammals.
Part of this speciesist social structure is the institution of animal welfarism which teaches people that animal use is not an issue. Animal treatment may be, but only if other animals are subject to “unnecessary suffering,” the cornerstone concept in animal welfarism. We like to think that we can use other animals in ways that avoids them suffering. Indeed, that is the promise of animal welfarism: the non-cruel use of other animals. Welfarism tends to regard the killing of other animals as not constituting a harm to them, with some welfarist positions suggesting that other animals are replaceable in this regard.
Even though many people may say that they “do not care” about other animals, few actually seem to believe that humans are free to do absolutely anything we want to do to them. Other animals are regarded as items of sentient property, suggesting that most people recognise that they have a welfare that should be protected to some degree.
It is not often, for example, that we’d meet a person who sees nothing wrong when they hear news that some human put a small animal into a microwave oven, or has slashed horses in fields, or likes to have sex with other animals until they die. People may suggest that their opposition to these things is based on indirect duties [1] we have to other animals but many will recognise that we have some direct duties to them that would not allow such forms of animal use. The use of animal property is permissible in speciesist society, but there are limits to such use.
The reality is that speciesist individuals prefer to keep the nuts and bolts of the way we use animals out of their consciousness.
We should recognise that we are still in the pioneer stage when it comes to veganism. The term only came into being in 1944 when veganism as a social movement emerged, and veganism as the moral baseline of the movement is very new as an accepted idea (not forgetting that many animal advocates still do not accept it – some go out of their way to mock the idea). This means that, at this stage, we need to reach those people most willing to consider new ideas. If we can get through to enough of them, the support for the justice-for-all philosophy of veganism will grow and, in terms of the availability of plant-based and non-animal consumables, the law of supply and demand will ensure that more vegan goods will become available, making it easier for the next generation of humans to live vegan.
The trick is knowing - or guessing - what would represent critical mass on this: 10%, 30%, 40%, 50%, 60%?
The best way for vegan advocates to respond to people who say that they do not “care about animals” at all is to think that they are not ready yet; that they are thoroughly socialised speciesists, and that they are part of that percentage of the population who will need to be forced to live vegan by the weight of numbers of people already living vegan. The weight of social opinion can be very heavy, so this is the “force” being referred to here.
We often say that such resistant people are “pre-vegans” – and yet, some individuals are more open to new ideas and ways of thinking than others. It makes little sense for vegan activists to spend too much time banging their head against a brick wall of resistance that some people construct and re-construct in defence of their oppressive behaviours and attitudes. Such individuals will find ways not to embrace the philosophy of veganism and discover the smallest reasons to drop veganism like a hot coal at the first opportunity. In next to no time, if they believe themselves to be part of the animal advocacy movement, they will be advocating for vegans to consume animal products, or suggest that a vegan can be sexist, racist, or even fascist.[2] Those things are the polar opposite of the justice-for-all origins of veganism and what veganism should stand for as a radical social movement. Such things certainly have no place within a rights-based social movement which, I argue, veganism should be.
Some people are high maintenance in social justice movement terms. Better for us, as vegans, to keep putting out the straightforward, justice-rich, vegan message, and see how many people there are “out there” who will become ethical vegans. Once the numbers of vegans grow who live vegan because of the ethics of vegan philosophy, the logic of the numbers game will mean that many more will come on board as the vegan movement grows.
Vegan advocates: please do not feel that you need to concentrate on those most resistant to your justice-for-all message – those who may reduce, or insist that vegetarianism is enough, or believe we have no moral duties with respect to other animals, or none above those prescribed by animal welfarism. Instead, push at more easily opened doors and try to get others already involved in social justice struggles to see the logic and strength in vegan ethics. Call it “alliance politics” and/or “intersectionality” if you want, but it makes a lot of sense to talk to others who already “get” issues of social justice than those who do not. This way, we might just win in the numbers game!
[1] This is how rights-based philosopher, Tom Regan, begins to look at the issue of indirect duties to other animals.
We begin by asking how the moral status of animals has been understood by thinkers who deny that animals have rights. Then we test the mettle of their ideas by seeing how well they stand up under the heat of fair criticism. If we start our thinking in this way, we soon find that some people believe that we have no duties directly to animals, that we owe nothing to them, that we can do nothing that wrongs them. Rather, we can do wrong acts that involve animals, and so we have duties regarding them, though none to them. Such views may be called indirect duty views. By way of illustration: suppose your neighbour kicks your dog. Then your neighbour has done something wrong. But not to your dog. The wrong that has been done is a wrong to you. After all, it is wrong to upset people, and your neighbour's kicking your dog upsets you. So you are the one who is wronged, not your dog. Or again: by kicking your dog your neighbour damages your property. And since it is wrong to damage another person's property, your neighbour has done something wrong - to you, of course, not to your dog. Your neighbour no more wrongs your dog than your car would be wronged if the windshield were smashed. Your neighbour's duties involving your dog are indirect duties to you. More generally, all of our duties regarding animals are indirect duties to one another — to humanity.
[from Regan’s chapter in In Defence of Animals, 1985 - http://www.animal-rights-library.com/texts-m/regan03.htm]
[2] Some of these suggestions will, of course, also come from outside of the animal advocacy movement. For example, the Francione opposition movement to animal advocacy suggested recently that vegans can be sexist – and that veganism is not co-extensive with everything that is right morally. This directly flies in the face of Donald Watson’s assertion that veganism is “the greatest cause on earth” - see sociologist Matthew Cole on that).