Products
A Campaign Lesson from Al Gore: Baby Steps Don't work
Filed · A guest post by Dr Roger Yates
Just over a year ago I went with a second Vegan Information Project volunteer to an event in Dublin entitled, “Climate Conversations 2015 Launch Event: Communicating the Challenge” which featured, among others, Eamon Ryan of the Green Party in Ireland, Claire O'Connor, former international director for Vice President Al Gore's Alliance for Climate Protection, Oisín Coghlan of Friends of the Earth, and media expert Terry Prone. This was the first of five events about the challenge of climate change.
A couple of things cropped up during the night which are highly relevant to the animal advocacy movement, especially at the moment. One topic in particular. Claire O’Connor said that one strategy she was involved in during her time in Gore’s organising team was suggesting to people that they begin by doing fairly easy things that will help the environment. The first thing suggested was to change light bulbs to environmentally-friendly ones.
The strategy is simple, and often known as “foot-in-the-door.” When people get used to doing this relatively easy thing, they may and more easily will move on to other things that they can do for the environment, eventually something like changing the type of car that they own.
This is a sensible and reasonable incremental strategy they thought. Don’t want to scare people off by asking them to do something substantial right from the get go. Sound familiar?
However, they found that many people did not necessarily “progress” to more meaningful activities that would help the environment, and so they set about to find out why.
They were told by many people in the subsequent research that it had been suggested to them that changing light bulbs “would be great” for the environment. They said, in effect, “I’ve changed the light bulbs, so now I’m tackling climate change.”
O’Connor says that their initial strategy has subsequently been called into question due to its failure in terms of driving substantial change. People simply did not move incrementally from one environmentally-friendly measure to another. People often stop at the baby steps. The Gore team are now trying to find out if being straightforward and honest about what they really wanted people to do would have been a better strategy right from the start.
While this story was unfolding, I began to think about the campaigns in the animal advocacy movement to encourage “meat reducers” - and the endeavours to motivate people to participate in “Meatless Mondays.” These appear to be comparable “easy-goes,” “baby-steps” campaigns going to ultimately fail just like the environmental ones described by O'Connor.
Might it be the case that actually telling people the truth is best from the beginning? Go on, utter that word: “VEGAN.” Take a breath and try again: “VEGAN.” There, wasn’t too hard, was it? Vegans – you want people to live vegan, right? So perhaps that’s what we vegans should ask of people. Nice and open - and nice and honest.
Let the vegetarians campaign for vegetarianism, and let the reducetarians try to influence the “meat reducers.” You, dear vegans, have grown-up vegan work to do.
The other issue that came up was raised by Terry Prone in her very entertaining talk. She said we can think, essentially, of three types of people.
1. The Converted.
2. The Unconvertible.
3. The Undecided.
Don’t bother talking too much to the number 1s, they are already on your side, she said, and it’s pretty much a complete waste of time talking to the 2s. Your audience are the 3s, the undecided, and probably the majority to boot.
Brendan said that we in the animal advocacy movement have this unfortunate habit of socially constructing “the enemy” who we can hate and campaign against. In Prone’s schema, these are the 2s, those we’ll never convince.
We often feel that we must challenge, attack, and scare, such people: we call them the “animal abusers.” However, this is directing limited resources towards pushing at the door least likely to open. We see from the hunting “bans” in Scotland, England, and Wales that, if the dominant culture is not changed, then the “animal abusers” will find every loophole they can to get around legislation. And then the animal movement is left appealing to a speciesist police force and a speciesist “justice system” for help that rarely comes in any way we find satisfactory.
Interestingly, Prone said that, in the fullness of time, the 2s will just have to be forced to buckle to our will with laws and legislation but after the 3s have been won over.
In the animal advocacy movement, it is often said that we should engage with the political system with the aim of achieving “animal-friendly” laws, rules, and regulations. That may be so – although the anarchist within each of us will surely object to that. In any event, what is certain right now is that right now is NOT the time for political campaigning. It’s way too early for that. That’s another closed door with rusty old hinges, certainly in terms of meaningful rights-based animal rights change.
Our job is to bring about cultural change and that means talking to the 3s. And remember where we started, be open and honest with them, right now!
Visit THE VEGFEST EXPRESS free online vegan magazine for latest vegan news updated 24-7 - http://www.vegfestexpress.co.uk