Animals
Why Do Animal Rightists Engage in Animal Welfare Campaigning When it is Not Necessary?
Filed · A guest post
Those who use and abuse other animals cannot countenance the idea of a rights-based position on the use of other animals. However, they claim to fully understand, support, and are strictly committed to the principles of the ideology of animal welfarism which essentially suggests that the non-cruel use of other animals is both feasible and morally acceptable.
This means that when animal-using counter-movement interests interact with state agencies and regulators, the only language they can use is the language of animal welfare – the view that “we'll treat [other] animals well while we exploit and kill them.” They cannot - on any level - understand the issue of the use of other animals in terms of rights-based animal rights. They simply cannot think of other animals as rights bearers, and they cannot allow themselves to believe that the use of other animals amounts to the commission of rights violations.
Of course, counter-movements and government agencies are not the only ones who have difficulty seeing other animals as right-holders, or resist regarding the use of other animals as rights violations. This is also not the usual way by which the mainstream animal advocacy movement frames the issue of animal use. Even those sections of the animal movement who go under the banner of “animal rights” often reject the philosophy of animal rights as laid out by rights-based theorists such as Tom Regan. The mainstream animal movement tends to talk about treatment rather than use, and speaks about acts of animal cruelty issues rather than rights violations on the alleged grounds that the public understands the former and reacts negatively to the latter.
This is why I use the term rights-based animal rights to mark its differences and philosophical departure from rhetorical “animal rights” which, regrettably, is the norm in modern-day animal advocacy. It remains a sobering thought to me at least that only a minority in the “animal rights movement” are rightists. One wonders why, in a movement made up largely of people who care little about, or actually oppose, rights-based philosophy, that the name “animal rights” is so popular. The answer, of course, is that it is used merely as a label with no philosophical substance.
Animal Rightists and the Regulation of Animal Rights Violations.
Rights-based animal rights advocates need not themselves get deeply involved in the incredibly messy business of welfare regulation. The regulation of atrocities and rights violations does not have an envious track record in the spheres of human rights or other than human animal rights. What animal rights advocates can do – and should do in my view - is maintain their rights-based claims-making about what happens to other animals - and let the mainstream animal movement and the animal user industries translate that into welfare. They will anyway. After all, welfarists do welfare.
There is little need or justification for the grassroots (especially) of the animal movement to engage in welfare campaigning. The reasons in support of this argument are based on the work of sociologist Richard Gale, and are predicated on the idea that there is a three-way relationship among social movements, their counter-movements, and (broadly) the state - or specific state agencies.
There may be a complex web on interactions among these groups or entities but one of the strongest links is thought to be between a social movement’s counter-organisation(s) and relevant government agencies. In clear terms, then, this may be a close working relationship between, for example, the meat and dairy industries and the Ministry of Agriculture in a given country. The counter-movement interests often enjoy what political scientist and co-author of The Animal Rights Debate, Robert Garner, calls “insider status.”
The general idea is that the creation of what I tend to call “turbulence” in society increases the already frequent interactions between the counter-movements and the state agencies. It is important to remind ourselves that both these groupings are deeply speciesist in nature and so, quite naturally, from their own perspectives, the only way they can “get their heads around” animal rights claims is to translate them “down” into animal welfarism which, as said, they not only understand but declare support for.
As an example, consider the case of a visiting circus with other animal “performers” which, if met by animal rights criticisms - animal use is wrong, animal use amounts to rights violations, etc. – usually respond by saying that their “care” for the other animals in their charge is excellent and, moreover, they are regularly inspected by officials from established animal welfare organisations and are often given a clean bill of health from inspectors.
They do not address the animal use issue or the rights violations issue because they cannot address them. Moreover, they probably have difficulty understanding their other animal-using businesses in such terms. Therefore, when counter-movement representatives meet with state agency staff, all parties are unlikely to be able to make any sense of what’s going on except within orthodox welfarist terms about how other animals are – and should be - treated. The animal rights claims about opposition to other animal use are beyond their terms of reference.
What may happen, then, is that through countermovement-state dialogue, pressure is exerted on the user industry to encourage it to effectively “clean up its act” if, for example, some form of abusive animal use has been exposed by a new open rescue or another form of educative investigation. What transpires in this scenario is the enactment of animal welfare regulation or the review and strengthening of existing animal welfare law, accompanied by loud media announcements of welfare improvements.
The way to move forward for a rights-based movement is to concentrate on the demand side of things by getting as many people as possible to understand and act upon the philosophical case for animal rights. As with the case of interconnected case of veganism, Donald Watson’s notion of “ripening up” applies. In other words, just as the public needs to be ripened to the radical intersectional philosophy of veganism, we also need to promote the case for animal rights and not water things down to welfare positions.
For a rights-based animal movement to grow and flourish, it must first be prepared to adhere to the philosophy of animal rights and stop sliding into welfare at virtually every given opportunity. There should be no fears that such campaigning is “leaving other animals to suffer in the here and now,” which is often said by welfare reform supporters. First, there are welfare groups who will never campaign for animal rights that will conduct direct welfare campaigns, and, secondly, as we’ve seen above, consistent rights-based animal advocacy encourages the development of welfare measures anyway.
Just as there is no need for vegans to engage in less-than-vegan advocacy, animal rightists can concentrate on animal rights campaigning aimed at completely ending the human use of other animals.