Vegfest Express Skip to content

UK News

Do Vegans Need Vitamins?

Filed · From the VegfestUK news archive

Traders unpacking crates and laying a cloth over a trestle table before opening (AI-generated image) AI
Setting up · AI-generated imageFIG. 01

In this guest blog, vegan cookbook author Tony Bishop-Weston discusses the role that vitamins play in an optimal plant-based diet.

The natural diet vs a synthesised diet and the consequential arguments about the natural suitability of a vegan diet is one of the most hotly debated ongoing arguments on social media.

The National Diet and Nutrition Study reveals many UK women are dangerously low in key nutrients:

The Robert Clack School study supported by Vitabiotics showed that a multivitamin and multimineral combined with an Omega 3 supplement may help with children’s academic progress via improved behaviour.

The question of whether vegans need vitamins is a very loaded question and you may as well be asking how long is a piece of string. It also depends on your views on health insurance.

It’s generally always good to start at the beginning.

Planet Vegan

Vegans are not from some alien planet with special non-human nutritional needs. Just like everyone else extra nutritional needs depend on diet, absorption and health. A vegan who includes yeast extract, fortified foods, tempeh and chlorella in their diet is no more likely to need vitamin extra B12 than the next person. However, the next person would probably benefit from extra vitamin B12 too. Vitamin B12 is such an important vitamin it’s essential to ensure you get enough, but just like other nutrients vitamin B12 absorption is dependent on other supporting vitamins. A good vegan multivitamin should have the same menu, just made with vegan ingredients - just like a good vegan pizza.

The idea that vegans need a specialist random list of a few extra nutrients based on what vegans do and don’t eat is an idea best avoided.

“Multi” Multi

If you are going to take a multivitamin, it sounds obvious, but make sure it’s a multivitamin. A good multivitamin usually has around 27-30 nutrients in it and avoids fillers such as Magnesium stearate or talc. "Look for a true full spectrum of multivitamin and mineral which includes a comprehensive range of essential nutrients as nutrients often work in synergy with each other," says Yvonne Bishop-Weston Nutritional Therapist, “and have nutrients at levels which are more reflective of our potentially higher need with hectic lifestyles and food grown and processed to contain fewer nutrients than we expect. Support optimal nutrition rather than the bare minimum to only help prevent deficiency diseases," says Yvonne.

There are a number of nutrients that often come in a non-vegan form such as vitamin D3 (from lanolin derived from sheep’s wool) or vitamin K from a bovine source. Capsules can be made from gelatin made from fish, cow or pigs.

100% Vegan

The easiest way to be sure a supplement is vegan is to look for the Vegan Society or Vegetarian Society’s vegan logo and check it is currently registered with them as they will have checked it. Without it don’t be surprised to find vegan plant-based nutrients claimed to be ‘veggie’ but then encapsulated in a fish based capsule or even containing fish oil. Vitamin D3 from sheep wool is deemed by the Vegetarian Society as vegetarian, although Vegan vitamin D3 can now be made from mushrooms or lichen.

Make sure you get the best value for money in a supplement by checking for minerals that are in the most absorbable form.

Horse Pills

Some minerals such as calcium and magnesium are needed in proportionally larger amounts, so you won’t find them in therapeutic amounts in a multivitamin or the pill would be too big to swallow. Fortunately, these minerals are found in abundance particularly in green leafy vegetables, beans and seeds. If you have a deficiency, choose minerals in a form that is the most absorbable version you can afford as the cheapest is not always the best value for money. Cheap iron supplements can leave you feeling sick or constipated so then you’ll forget to take them and then they don’t work.

"Post-menopausal women, vegan or not are likely to benefit from taking additional minerals for their bones," says Yvonne.

There are some things you won’t usually find in a multivitamin, even a good one.

Essential Fats

Humans can make saturated fat – just look at people who eat a lot of processed sugary foods or who drink a lot of alcohol with their takeaway food and crisps. Modern humans, particularly men, find it harder than it should be to do what algae do and make long chain fatty acids EPA and DHA from basic essential omega 3 fats found in linseed/flaxseed, hemp, chia, walnuts, purslane, cress, rapeseed etc. This could be a lack of supporting nutrients, an imbalance of other fats using up those supporting nutrients and enzymes, stressful lifestyles using up those supporting nutrients or in some other mechanism thwarting the body’s efficiency in converting these fats. Health professionals suggest eating fish (but not too much because of toxins found in modern fish) as although fish have lots of saturated fat they also have pre-converted long-chain polyunsaturated fats that they have gleaned from eating algae (or eating other fish that have eaten other fish that have eaten algae) Of course just as with calcium you can cut out the middleman (animal) and just consume algae yourself.

Good Bacteria

The old adage ‘the way to a man’s heart is through his stomach’ could be truer than anyone previously thought. The more we know, we find the less we knew. There seems to be something in the modern diet and lifestyle that is clearly at odds with an optimal balance of good bacteria in our digestive systems. A lack of enough vegetables in our diet may play a part, but other factors are at play too. Abuse of lifesaving anti-biotics seem an obvious culprit, other drugs? environmental toxins? new superviruses? additives in processed food such as binders and sweeteners? No one has yet come up with a definitive proven answer but like everything else, the scientific truth is probably confounded by a cocktail of chemicals separately generally regarded as safe but combined just cumulatively overwhelm our delicate human systems. What we do know is that the balance of bacteria in our gut seems to be at the heart of a healthy immune system and we now have a fraction of the variety and volume of our ancestors and surviving ancient cultures (no pun intended) Imbalances of bacteria in our gut have been linked to virtually everything from obesity to mood problems and depression. Although traditionally good bacteria was synonymous with dairy there are now a number companies nurturing vegan cultures hence the explosion of artisan vegan cheeses, yoghurt and kefir as well as specialist health supplements.

Food not pills

If you’d rather not take supplements, then there are a number of things you can do to reassure yourself that you are getting enough of the essential nutrients.

  1. Go to your GP and ask for a blood test, they won’t routinely test for vitamin B12 as blood has to be centrifuged but probably will if you say you are vegan. They will sometimes even test essential fat levels. They will routinely test iron levels which at least will give you a basic idea if you are absorbing nutrients efficiently (providing you are eating a healthy diet).
  2. Use a programme such as checkyourfood.com to check your recipes and foods for the macro- and micro-nutrients in your food and work out if you are getting enough of key nutrients. It can suggest enhancements.
  3. Visit a qualified, experienced, insured, registered Nutritional Therapist. If necessary, they can arrange comprehensive laboratory tests to find out exactly what’s going on in your body.

Competition

About the author

Tony Bishop-Weston Vegan is consultant development chef with Foods for Life Health and Nutrition, author and former business development advisor with The Vegan Society and The Vegetarian Society. @bishopweston

www.newforesthealth.com www.twitter.com/BeaulieuHealth

More from UK News

More from UK News