Reports
The Long History of Avoiding Animal Products
Filed
The word vegan dates from 1944, coined in Leicester by Donald Watson and a small group who wanted a term for vegetarians who also avoided dairy and eggs. The practice it describes is very much older, and the confusion between the two is worth clearing up before reading any claim about who was first. The same problem occurs with living people, where a label attaches faster than anyone checks it; which public figures are actually vegan separates the documented cases from the mistaken ones.
The earliest well-documented advocate in the European tradition is Pythagoras, whose followers were reported by later writers to abstain from meat. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy is the useful starting point here rather than a popular summary, because it is explicit about how thin and how late the sources are: almost nothing survives from Pythagoras himself, and what is attributed to him comes through writers working centuries afterwards. Anyone citing him as a vegetarian is citing a tradition about him, not a text by him.
Why the distinction matters for reading this archive
The reports in this file were written during a period when the historical argument was used frequently in festival talks, and it was used loosely. A speaker asserting that the practice is two and a half thousand years old is making a claim that the surviving evidence only partly supports. The claim about abstention in the ancient world is defensible; the claim that it resembled a modern vegan diet is not.
Indian traditions have a better-documented and continuous record of principled abstention, and a reader who wants the older thread will find more there than in the Greek material. The archive touches this only glancingly, in talks about regional Indian cooking and in one strand of the wellbeing programming.
The nineteenth century is where the institutions start
The organisational history is much firmer than the ancient one. The Vegetarian Society was founded in 1847 in Ramsgate, and the Vegan Society followed in 1944. Both remain active, and the Vegan Society appears often in the reports collected here, as a stallholder and a supplier of speakers instead of as an organiser.
That institutional continuity is the reason the 2015 to 2019 circuit had a ready supply of programme content. A festival needing a talk on nutrition or on the history of the movement could ask an organisation that had been answering the same questions for decades. The talks recorded in this archive are frequently the same talks, given by the same organisations, in a different room.
What changed in the period this archive covers
The argument shifted while the history stayed the same. Early reports in the file lead with ethics and animal welfare. From 2016 onwards the environmental case appears more often, and by 2018 and 2019 the health and performance case is doing more of the work, particularly in the athlete-focused programming. None of those arguments is new, and the interesting thing is the change in which one gets top billing.
For a reader tracing that shift, the year archives are the better route than the sections, because the change is chronological, not topical.
Three claims that recur and how they hold up
The first is that vegetarianism is an ancient and continuous Western tradition. This overstates the evidence. There are ancient advocates, and there are long gaps, and the modern movement is a nineteenth-century institutional creation, not an unbroken line.
The second is that a named historical figure was vegan. This is almost always wrong on a technicality that matters: the avoidance of eggs and dairy is the distinguishing feature of veganism, and for most historical figures the sources do not record their position on either. Vegetarian is usually the defensible word.
The third is a specific figure for how long people have avoided meat, most often two and a half thousand years. That number traces to the Pythagorean material, and it inherits all of that material's problems: late sources, no surviving text from the person named, and a tradition that grew in the retelling.
Why this matters for the archive
Because these three claims appear in talk summaries throughout the file, and the archive reports them without adjudicating them. That is the correct behaviour for a record: it preserves what was said. It does mean a reader should treat a historical claim in a talk summary as evidence about the talk instead of evidence about history.
Questions about this piece
When was the word vegan coined?
In 1944, in Leicester, by Donald Watson and a small group who wanted a term for vegetarians who also avoided dairy and eggs. The practice long predates the word.
Was Pythagoras a vegetarian?
A tradition about him says so. Almost nothing survives from Pythagoras himself, and the reports come through writers working centuries later, so the claim rests on a tradition instead of a text.
Which is the better-documented older tradition?
The Indian traditions have a more continuous and better-attested record of principled abstention than the Greek material does.
Did the arguments change across 2015 to 2019?
The order of billing changed. Ethics led early, the environmental case grew from 2016, and health and athletic performance were prominent by 2018 and 2019.