Reports
Resistance to the Francione Countermovement
Filed · From the VegfestUK news archive
What follows is a report from one individual involved in a campaign of sorts against the bullying of Gary Francione. It is an individual account, not a group report.
Law professor Gary Francione has, for many years, applied a harsh and totally unrealistic standard to groups and individuals in the animal advocacy movement.
One technical issue needs to be dealt with at this initial stage. Readers should recognise that Gary Francione does not include himself in the membership of the animal advocacy movement. He sees himself as an outsider to all other animal mobilisations, which he generally labels “animal welfarist,” whether that name is accurate or otherwise. Francione further believes that no other animal advocates on the planet stand for veganism and, whether that is accurate or not, this belief is the grounds for calling others names in repeated attacks.
Of course, many groups are welfarist in outlook – and that is the name they will happily apply to themselves. This concept of “animal welfarist” needs to be divided into two types: it relates to traditional welfarism and “new” or “neo” welfarism. Traditional animal welfarists are those who want to improve how other animals are treated while they are being used by humans, but they are not opposed to that use. Organisations that “fit” this category are the HSUS, the RSPCA, and Compassion in World Farming (CIWF).
The concept of new welfarism is more problematic and political. When Francione came up with the idea in 1996, it was a concept used to differentiate traditional and new welfarists. Many new welfarists were recognised by Francione as abolitionists who were appealing to a problematic theory and applying a faulty methodology, which can be summed up as animal welfare plus animal welfare plus animal welfare = animal rights. It is also important to note that the original conception of new welfarist occurred before Francione virtually abandoned the concept of animal rights. Francione’s early work is heavily indebted to the scholarship of rights-based philosopher, Tom Regan. For example, Francione wrote in 1995, “The debt I owe Professor Tom Regan is clear… Regan’s theory of animal rights provided a framework against which I could evaluate my claim that current laws that regulate our treatment of animals do not result in respect-based rights for animals.” [1]
A year later, Francione was to defined “new welfarist” thus
[The] rejection of rights by animal advocates does not necessarily mean that all of these advocates have simply embraced some version of classical [traditional] welfarism. Many modern animal advocates see the abolition of animal exploitation as a long-term goal, but see welfarist reform, which seeks to reduce animal suffering, as setting the course for the interim strategy. [2]
Not many individuals or groups label themselves as new-welfarist; not in 1996, and especially not in the present day when it is used by Francione and his associates as an out-and-out insult. The damning insult “works” for Camp Francione because no longer are many new welfarists seen as abolitionists. By 2008, Francione was discussing at least three types of new welfarist, and it is clear that many, probably the majority, are no longer to be seen as abolitionists. [3]
Thus, in a sense, begins the tyranny of “The” Abolitionists. Essentially, Francione’s abolitionists believe that no others deserve the name, and, similarly, only they really stand for veganism unequivocally, and in terms of it being the moral baseline of their campaigning and claims-making.
Gary Francione’s movement – to the extent that he has one at all – is a countermovement to the existing animal movement. One means by which “The” Abolitionists seek to differentiate themselves from all others is by applying a guilt-by-association criteria to animal advocacy. For example, let us say that an organisation gets a grant from a funding body that has a staff member who is associated in some way with an animal welfare group, then Francione’s not-in-the-real-world guilt-by-association criteria states that the group that received the grant is promoting animal welfare due to all the connecting linkages.
In a recent blog entry I explained how ridiculous the guilt-by-association criteria is, using the group I volunteer with, the Vegan Information Project (VIP), as the example
We have to imagine that someone goes to a VIP street event in Ireland, likes what they see and hear; then goes to the VIP website for a look-see; then sees the VegFund sign, then goes to VegFund’s website; then are interested enough to check their staff members; then they discover Leslie Barcus is employed by VegFund; and then they discover that she’s on the board of Humane Society International and make something of that information. We are asked to believe that this tiny possibility negates all the street work that was done on the streets of Dublin due to one VegFund grand in 2013! [4]
Towards the end of March, 2016, a group of animal advocates, including myself, decided to apply Francione’s criteria to Francione. The conventional wisdom when one is attacked by Francione is to remain quiet, keep one’s head down, and wait for Camp Francione to move on to fresh pastures, so to speak. However, this does not prevent or even reduce the attacks.
Therefore, it was decided to take a stand – show some resistance for a change: what would be revealed if Francione’s guilt-by-association criteria was turned on law professor Gary L. Francione?
A great deal, as it happens! Let’s look at the Top Ten Guilt-By-Association Problems (yes there are more: another time perhaps).
Gary Francione is the main “star” of the “World Vegan Summit,” a conference organised by Bob Linden, the host of a radio show called “Go Vegan Radio.” The summit essentially exists to showcase Francione’s version of abolitionism and, as well as the main man himself appearing several times, and giving the keynote presentations, other Francione-approved guests and speakers appear as well.
The summit is heavily advertised on a weekly basis by Linden on the radio show and by Francione, who is a weekly guest on the show, and via his own FB page. Francione declares that, “The World Vegan Summit is the **only** national conference that promotes veganism as a moral baseline/imperative.” So how does the “World Vegan Summit” shape up under the Francione guilt-by-association spotlight?
Problem One.
For many weeks, the Francione/Linden summit was promoting Farm Fresh to You as a sponsor of the 2016 event. It was noticed that, along with the fresh fruits and vegetables, eggs were on offer from this sponsor. Neither Francione nor Linden knew of this, so it was pointed out to them. Linden removed the sponsor, making the excuse on the radio that the problem had not been spotted because the detail about the eggs was hidden away in, “the fine print pages into the web site.”
What Linden failed to tell his listeners was that, apart from this mention of eggs, Farm Fresh to You has an easily accessible recipe page featuring dishes that include “fish sauce,” Greek yoghurt, eggs, honey, and two types of dairy cheese.
By Francione’s own criteria, then, the Francione/Linden summit was promoting animal products for weeks.
Problem Two.
Summit sponsor, Compassion Inc., was found to be advertising jobs for PeTA and Animal Equality. They were also retweeting Vegan Outreach tweets.
They were also advertising a job for a café in Yorkshire which offers a whole farmyard of animal products such as Shepherds Purse Yorkshire Blue cheese, Organic Lye Cross cheddar and goat’s cheese, Butternut squash, lemon and goat’s cheese, and dairy quiche, “made with organic free range eggs, organic milk (quiche changes daily).”
By Francione’s own criteria, the Francione/Linden summit was promoting animal products for weeks. After weeks of this promotion, this World “Vegan” Summit sponsor has been removed.
Problem Three.
Summit sponsor Kindred Spirits Care Farm, whose students, “fixed [a] chicken coop,” and built, “a secure rabbit hutch,” which may or may not fall foul of Francione’s criteria, are funded by the Pollination Project, through their executive director, Karen Snook, and that certainly is unacceptable as far as Francione is concerned.
This sponsor is STILL a 2016 summit sponsor. By Francione’s standard, the Francione/Linden summit is presently promoting the Pollination Project.
Problem Four.
Summit sponsor the Vegan Health and Fitness Magazine runs stories about organisations such as PeTA, and individuals like former Vegan Society ambassador, Fiona Oakes. Francione attacks both.
This sponsor is STILL a 2016 summit sponsor. By Francione’s standard, the Francione/Linden summit is presently promoting PeTA and Fiona Oakes.
Problem Five.
Summit sponsor, Vegans Rock, proudly and uncritically announce that they will be sharing the stage at conferences with the likes of Gene Baur and Victoria Moran. Francione has attacked both.
This sponsor is STILL a 2016 summit sponsor. By Francione’s standard, the Francione/Linden summit is presently promoting Gene Baur and Victoria Moran.
Problem Six.
Summit sponsor VegKids are connected to “Kids LA,” which says that they take groups of children to Farm Sanctuary. Both Francione and Linden regularly attack Farm Sanctuary, saying that they are part of the “happy exploitation movement.”
This sponsor is STILL a 2016 summit sponsor. By Francione’s standard, the Francione/Linden summit is presently promoting Farm Sanctuary.
Problem Seven.
Summit sponsors, Sjaak’s Organic Chocolates note that their products may contain trace amounts of dairy. Francione attacked PeTA for being speciesist because they are rather fast and loose when it comes to trace ingredients. Francione writes: “And what is a “trace”? How much is “okay”? And what if it’s a “small” amount of meat? How is that different from a “small” amount of eggs or dairy? Answer: it isn’t.”
This sponsor is STILL a 2016 summit sponsor. By Francione’s standard, the Francione/Linden summit is presently promoting the possibility of consuming trace animal ingredients.
Problem Eight.
Summit sponsor, Food Not Bombs, state that they may use breads with dairy in them. They are also praised on the website by Will Potter, the author of Green is the New Red, who Francione attacks as a pseudo-radical and says is “pathetic.”
This sponsor is STILL a 2016 summit sponsor and speaker. By Francione’s standard, the Francione/Linden summit is presently promoting Will Potter and the use of breads with dairy in them.
Problem Nine.
Speakers at the 2015 World “Vegan” Summit promoted single-issue campaigns, PeTA, and Meatless Mondays. One speaker promoted Meatless Mondays during a summit speech. Are such speakers returning in 2016? Absolutely.
Problem Ten.
This one is not connected to the Francione/Linden summit. As noted above, the Vegan Information Project was attacked by Francione for receiving a single VegFund grant in 2013 for a pay-to-view event along with another vegan outreach group, Vegan Education on the Go (VEGO). In 2014, however, Francione and partner professor Anna Charlton accepted an invitation to speak in a series that was sponsored throughout by VegFund.
They may claim that they were not aware of this dread sponsorship before the event itself. However, they certainly knew of it during the event, because the organiser mentions the VegFund funding while introducing Francione and Charlton who were standing right there waiting to talk. Given the terribly problematic nature of receiving funding from this, in Francione’s eyes, disgusting group, did they bring this up during more than a hour of talking – no.
There is a YouTube video of this talk, VegFund promotion included, while “The” Abolitionist stands silent. By Francione’s own criteria, he is promoting VegFund through this video.
Please note.
In writing this blog entry, I am not saying that I disagree with some of the criticism made, sometimes by Francione himself, of some of these groups, and some of these individuals mentioned.
Also, the entire idea behind this resistance to Francione’s bullying is to expose the ludicrous nature of Francione’s guilt-by-association criteria. No-one is necessarily suggesting that these sponsors should not be sponsors and/or speakers at the 2016 “World Vegan Summit.” No-one wants anyone to lose money over the collapse of the summit.
[1] Francione, G.L. (1995) Animals, Property, and the Law. Philadelphia: Temple University Press, xvi-xvii.
[2] Francione, G.L. (1996) Rain Without Thunder: The Ideology of the Animal Rights Movement. Philadelphia: Temple University Press. 34.
[3] Francione, G.L. (2008) Animals as Persons: Essays on the Abolition of Animal Exploitation. New York: Columbia University Press, 14-21.
[4] Yates, R. (2016) “The Vegan Information Project and the Francione Countermovement.” Blog entry, 12th April, On Human Relations with Other Sentient Beings. http://onhumanrelationswithothersentientbeings.weebly.com/the-blog/the-vegan-information-project-and-the-francione-countermovement