Reports
Resistance to the Francione Countermovement #2. Campaigning in Glass Houses: How the Francione Camp Responds to Criticism.
Filed · A guest post
Social movement theory suggests that modern social movements are messy entities, and the closer one looks, the messier they seem to be. Early social movement theorists looked at campaigning mobilisations from afar, and in the abstract. However, in the late 1960s, sociologists and other social scientists became involved in protests and campaigns - and then they saw for themselves how complex and messy social movements really are.
Until very recently, the Gary Francione countermovement to animal advocacy adopted this hands-off, abstract, rather aloof, approach. Even now, they are much more content in expending their energies on demolition rather than building an alternative animal movement.
However, Camp Francione now sincerely believes that they, at long last, have the beginnings of a viable social movement of their own. It is not very visible – a few infrequent fold-down tables dotted around the world: and once-a-month seems to be the very best they can manage thus far. This is why, when animal advocates know anything at all about Gary Francione and his associates, it is that they spend most of their time slagging off the existing animal advocacy movement, both the good and the bad. Few street activists seem to spread the news that there’s a new and fresh kid on the campaigning block to be looked at. Sadly, that is because there isn’t one to be recommend and, with the amount of rigid social control Francione requires over his followers, an operational Francione movement is unlikely to emerge anytime soon.
They do have a “national conference,” though, the second one due shortly.
Camp Francione have dipped their toes into the messy business of actually doing something – and they’ve had their fingers burnt. They are finding out that it’s not so easy out there in the real world. Painful compromises may need to be made – and Camp Francione have learnt to make such compromises quickly, from continuing to promote several problematic conference sponsors and speakers, to accepting speaking engagements funded by organisations whose policies are not totally aligned with their own.
After spending many years calling out others on their position, or when they try to get things done, how have Camp Francione responded to reasoned criticism? Predictably, their reaction has been extremely poor. Rather than address the real substantive problems pointed out, they have closed ranks, blocked people on social media, and gone into denial.
For example, Francione stalwart and trusty, Bob Linden, has sought to minimise the problems as much he possibly can while attacking the messengers. For example, towards the end of March, and early April, 2016, Linden had to be told about the problematic nature of some of the sponsors of the “World Vegan Summit.” Apparently, their problematic nature had been totally overlooked.[1]
It was drawn to his attention that one of his sponsors, Farm Fresh to You, featured on their website an easily-accessible recipe page that featured all sorts of animal ingredients such as eggs and dairy, and sauces made out of the bodies of fishes. However, on his radio show, which is called “Go Vegan Radio,” he does his very best to downplay the issue.
Click to listen (25 seconds)
After years pointing out the problems in other organisations, what did Camp Francione do when issues are pointed out to them? Did they address the issues? No, they preferred to call the messengers, “weirdos.”
Click to listen (2 mins 39 – content warning for ableist language)
In the above clips all taken from the same radio show, Bob Linden says on four occasions that the “World Vegan Summit” is accused of promoting the consumption of “meat, dairy, fish, and eggs.” This is not the case. No summit sponsor, as far as I’m aware, promotes the consumption of animal flesh (“meat”) and that “accusation” was never made.
Moreover, in relation to the comments about Food Not Bombs and Will Potter, either Linden does not fully understand how Gary Francione’s guilty-by-association criteria works, or else he pretends not to understand that, in Francione’s world, associations, however weak, condemn.
Toward the end of the audio clip, Linden says he, Francione, and the summit is accused of supporting groups (he names PeTA and Farm Sanctuary here) that the Francione countermovement regards as “sell outs,” and “animal betrayal specialists.” This is technically untrue: they have been accused of promoting these groups – which they still are doing via their sponsors’ page. Not they’ve dipped their toes a little into the world of actually doing stuff, it appears that a “business decision” has been made to keep the sponsors (and some conference speakers) who promote organisations Camp Francione routinely attack.
In the following clip, Linden gets into a heated debate with a caller named Charles, who claims to have alerted Linden in December 2015 to the fact that a company being promoted had items containing animal products in them and yet it took more than seven weeks for Linden to remove the offending company. Linden tries unsuccessfully to end Charles’ call at 2:26, fails again at 3:55, and finally manages it at 4:22.
The point Charles alludes to – and it is a valid point – is what would Camp Francione make of a seven week delay in removing the promotion of animal products - if it were done by anyone other than themselves?
Click to listen (4 mins 53 – again warning about ableist language)
Social Media.
Camp Francione routinely ban and block people on social media such as Facebook. They then claim that no-one can provide a substantive critique of their position or activities. This works for them in two ways. First, by banning people; and Francione says that he gets a thrill out of doing it, they prevent discourse enabling them to declare to supporters that no-one has mounted any sort of challenge.
Secondly, Francione himself reserves the absolute right to decide what other contributors to his page are doing, and the right to label other’s mode of conduct in any way he chooses. For example, people may go to “The” Abolitionist Facebook page and, as far as they are concerned, make reasoned and polite points. However, they find themselves banned and blocked with Francione claiming that their contribution was, in reality - his reality, abusive and/or irrational.
In 2011, I wrote that “The” Abolitionists are not fit for purpose when it comes to running a social movement organisation. Sadly, that remains the case. Moreover, I suspect that, due to the strict social control he requires, Francione knows deep down that he could not tolerate a movement in his name – especially not a mass movement – because it would get a little messy and he would simply lose a lot of control.
Keeping control, in the end, is more important than really getting “out there” educating the population about veganism which, happily, so many outside of “The” Abolitionists do, and do well – on a weekly basis.
[1]. Problematic by Camp Francione’s not-of-this-world guilt-by-association criteria.